BlackRock's spot Bitcoin ETF iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) recorded an outflow of $541.1 million on November 19 — the largest single-day withdrawal in the fund's entire history. IBIT now accounts for the bulk of outflows from U.S. spot Bitcoin funds for the current month.
The distribution of selling proved extremely uneven. On the same day, the competing Morgan Stanley fund attracted $49.6 million, while virtually all redemption orders were concentrated in IBIT.
The bulk of the money is leaving through BlackRock
On Thursday, the 12 funds lost a combined $582.3 million — the strongest outflow session of November — and IBIT accounted for about 93% of the total.
The same dynamic holds for the month overall. Investors withdrew roughly $3.47 billion from U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs over 14 trading sessions. IBIT accounts for about $2.94 billion of that sum — nearly 85%. The fund recorded outflows on 13 of the 14 days.
However, these outflows reflect redemptions of shares by investors — BlackRock does not make the decision to sell assets. Scale matters too: since launch, IBIT has gathered $63.4 billion in net inflows, so the November withdrawals represent less than 5% of that amount.
Why the cheapest fund keeps attracting money
The Morgan Stanley Bitcoin Trust (MSBT), launched in April, charges a 0.14% annual fee versus 0.25% for IBIT. In November, MSBT saw inflows of about $108.7 million — with only one day of outflows. On Thursday, the fund received its largest inflow of the month.
The numbers do not support a mass migration from one fund to another: November inflows into MSBT do not even reach 4% of the amount withdrawn from IBIT. Most investors are exiting Bitcoin ETFs entirely rather than seeking a lower fee.
The composition of holders also shapes the outflow pattern. Morgan Stanley can offer MSBT to clients through roughly 16,000 of its wealth management advisors. Such investors tend to add Bitcoin slowly to long-term portfolios, without tying themselves to a month's price swings.
IBIT is the industry's largest fund, and large holders reducing Bitcoin positions are most likely to sell assets there. If this theory is correct, MSBT will continue to attract money while IBIT loses it. If MSBT also starts losing money, the hypothesis will not be confirmed.
Outflows or inflows in IBIT are often viewed as an indicator of institutional demand for Bitcoin, but November's statistics paint a different picture: collectively, the other 11 funds lost about $527 million over the month — less than a fifth of the net outflow from IBIT alone.
Cryptalist analysis: The concentration of outflows in IBIT primarily reflects the holder structure of the largest fund, not a flight of institutions from the asset class as a whole. As long as MSBT maintains positive inflows at a lower fee, the market is demonstrating redistribution rather than an exodus. The key signal for assessing the resilience of institutional demand will be the performance of both funds in the coming trading sessions.