Bitcoin's key economic mechanism — the halving of the block reward — could turn from a scarcity driver into a source of systemic risk in 2028. If the price of the first cryptocurrency has not doubled by then, a significant portion of miners will be forced to shut down their equipment, which will lead to a drop in hash rate and a weakening of network security.

The discussion about the extreme pressures on the mining economy gained momentum after a post by a crypto community member under the pseudonym Purp, whose analysis garnered more than 164,000 views. The main thesis: the next halving is not a cause for optimism, but a serious test for the entire mining industry.

Miners are already operating at the limit of profitability

The Bitcoin network rewards miners for confirming transactions, and roughly every four years this reward is cut in half. The next halving will take place in 2028. The current economics of the industry look strained:

  • for each block, miners receive 3.125 BTC;
  • user fees add less than 1% to this amount;
  • mining is only profitable on new equipment and at an electricity price below roughly $0.08 per kWh;
  • hashprice — a miner's revenue per unit of power — is hovering near record lows.

After the halving, the reward will drop to 1.5625 BTC. Equipment and electricity costs will remain unchanged: miners will spend the same amount but earn half as much.

Miners leaving will weaken network security

The industry will stay in the black only if Bitcoin doubles in price. Otherwise, mining will become unprofitable, equipment will start being switched off, and along with that the hash rate — the total power of all devices mining Bitcoin — will fall. The lower the hash rate, the cheaper an attack on the network will cost.

The parallel with the model of Michael Saylor, founder of Strategy, which holds Bitcoin on its balance sheet, is telling: it works only as long as the price rises. According to Joel Valenzuela, a marketer for the Dash project, the security budget problem — the money the network pays miners for protection — remains underestimated. BTC supporters, in his assessment, are not prepared for such a scenario: most do not understand the essence of the problem, and the rest deny it. "Most likely, serious trouble will begin in 2028," Valenzuela concludes.

Cryptalist analysis: The mining economy is already in a phase of extreme pressure, and the 2028 halving could trigger a cascading reduction in hash rate in the absence of a twofold price increase. Institutional investors should take into account the correlation between miners' profitability, the network's security budget, and Bitcoin's resilience to 51% attacks — this risk is still poorly priced into market valuations.