Bots and mini-apps on Telegram can now charge for digital services exclusively in the messenger's internal currency — Stars. The platform's founder, Pavel Durov, publicly explained the logic behind this restriction on November 18 and identified the sole exception — VPN bots operating in authoritarian countries.
Where the restriction came from
The key reason is the requirements of Apple and Google. It is these corporations that determine whether an app stays in the App Store and Google Play. For this reason, bot and mini-app developers are deprived of the ability to accept any other payment methods for digital services.
It is not possible to pay directly with Gram coins (formerly known as Toncoin) inside a mini-app. However, holders of the asset have retained a workaround: Gram can be used to purchase Stars on the Fragment platform, and those can then be used to pay for a service. For coin holders, this means that Gram has not become a means of payment inside bots, but has remained a tool for topping up a Stars balance.
Durov separately singled out VPN bots operating in authoritarian countries. The rule does not apply to them — they are permitted to accept any payment. In his assessment, such services are "doing God's work."
Community reaction
Many commenters thanked him for the clarity. Mini-app developers noted that the rules had become clearer and asked for improved analytics on Stars payouts. Part of the audience called the exception for VPN services a correct step toward protecting privacy and circumventing censorship.
Criticism was also voiced. Subscribers raised several topics:
- rules should be transparent and the same for everyone, rather than changing to accommodate convenient services;
- it is unclear why the restriction cannot be introduced only in apps for iOS and Android, since Telegram has an Android version outside of Google Play;
- it is unclear what mini-apps of exchange services that take a commission in tokens should do;
- a buyer of Stars may request a refund from Apple or Google, and the developer will be left at a loss;
- the messenger has many scam bots, and there are calls to combat them more actively.
Some subscribers saw the post as a good sign for Gram. In their opinion, the coin will over time take a more prominent place in the messenger's economy.
Cryptalist analysis: The case demonstrates the fundamental dependence of the Telegram ecosystem on app store rules — the internal currency Stars is effectively becoming a mandatory settlement layer for digital services, which strengthens its role in the platform's economy. The selective exception for VPN bots emphasizes the priority of privacy in the project's strategy, but at the same time creates regulatory uncertainty and grounds for criticism from developers. For Gram holders, the signal is neutral-to-positive: the asset retains a utility function through Fragment, however its status as a means of payment inside bots remains limited.